When most families lose hope after one refusal, Jaswinder Kaur’s family decided to rise again — not once, but twice. Their journey is not just a story about a visa refusal; it is a story about faith tested, courage renewed, and justice finally restored. It is also a reflection of the times we live in, where Canadian immigration has become harder, colder, and more mechanical — yet families like Jaswinder Kaur’s continue to remind us that hope, patience, and persistence can still move mountains.
This is their story — a battle that began with a simple dream of visiting Canada as a family and ended in the Federal Court of Canada, not once but twice, until justice finally prevailed.
Every family dreams of being together. For Jaswinder Kaur, her husband, and their young daughter, the dream was simple: to visit Canada as a family under a Temporary Resident Visa (TRV), meet relatives, experience Canadian culture, and give their daughter the joy of family bonding beyond borders. They applied with sincerity and optimism, believing that their genuine intentions would speak for themselves.
Their first refusal came abruptly. The reasons were typical of what so many applicants now see: “Family ties and purpose of visit not established.” It was a cold and standardized response — one that disregarded the human side of immigration. Behind every checkbox, there was a family disappointed and disheartened. Behind every refusal, there was a father trying to explain to his child why they were not welcome. For this family, it felt like rejection not only by an institution but by a dream.
What made this situation even more painful was that the refusal extended to their minor daughter. She had no independent reason to be denied entry, no intention to remain in Canada, and no possible justification for being treated as inadmissible. Yet, the system refused to see her innocence. Whether it was human error or an automated decision made by an artificial intelligence tool, the result was the same: a family separated, their hope broken.
It was at this moment that they approached Fateh Law Corporation. They came not just for legal representation but for someone who could understand what they were going through. They were frustrated, confused, and on the verge of giving up. Many around them said there was nothing that could be done. But as a law firm built on the belief that every refusal tells a story worth challenging, Fateh Law Corporation decided to take their fight to the next level — the Federal Court of Canada.
On behalf of the family, the firm filed a judicial review application. The legal argument was simple yet powerful: the officer’s decision was unreasonable and lacked procedural fairness. The reasons given were generic, the assessment superficial, and the evidence ignored. The officer had failed to consider clear proof of strong home ties in India, including employment, family, and property. Financial documents, return tickets, and community commitments were all disregarded. The decision did not meet the standard of justification, transparency, and intelligibility required under Canadian law, especially under the principles laid down in Vavilov v. Canada (2019 SCC 65).
As the case progressed, the Department of Justice, representing IRCC, proposed a settlement. This meant that IRCC would agree to reconsider the application and issue a new, fair decision. For Jaswinder Kaur’s family, this was a sign of hope. They felt their voice had finally been heard, and they believed the nightmare was behind them. After months of anxiety, they looked forward to a genuine reconsideration and a fair chance.
But the system once again betrayed their trust. Months passed with no meaningful response from IRCC. The silence stretched on for nearly half a year. And then, another refusal arrived. This time, the officer claimed “insufficient proof of funds.” The same funds that had already been presented, verified, and accepted previously were now being questioned. It was clear that this was not a fresh, independent review. It was a mere repetition of the injustice they had already faced.
For the family, this was deeply discouraging. They had followed every instruction, provided every document, and waited in good faith. Yet, despite a settlement, they were refused again on grounds that made no sense. Fateh Law Corporation recognized that this was not just another refusal — it was an act of bad faith that undermined the very purpose of Federal Court settlements.
Rather than advising the family to give up, the firm encouraged them to fight again. They filed a second judicial review — another Federal Court challenge. This time, they not only contested the unreasonable refusal but also sought costs against IRCC for acting in bad faith and forcing the family to return to court after a prior settlement. The argument was that IRCC’s behavior constituted an abuse of process and a disregard for procedural fairness. It was a matter of principle — justice had to be defended, even if it meant going to court twice.
During this period, the family lived through unimaginable stress. Every day brought uncertainty. Their daughter, too young to understand bureaucracy, would ask simple questions that no parent could answer: “Why doesn’t Canada want us?” Nights were sleepless, and days were filled with waiting. The emotional toll of being caught in an unending legal process was immense.
But what makes families like Jaswinder Kaur’s remarkable is their strength. They continued to believe that truth would prevail. And Fateh Law Corporation continued to fight beside them, not just as lawyers but as advocates for fairness. The litigation team meticulously prepared submissions, affidavits, and supporting evidence, demonstrating that IRCC’s decisions had failed to meet the standard of reasonableness and fairness mandated under law.
After almost one and a half years of combined legal struggle — two Federal Court proceedings, months of follow-up, and countless communications — the victory finally came. The family received the long-awaited passport request. For anyone outside the immigration process, this may seem like just another procedural step. But for those who have lived through repeated refusals, it means everything. It means recognition, validation, and relief. It means a chance to finally breathe and move forward with dignity.
When the family called to share the news, their words were filled with gratitude. Jaswinder Kaur’s voice trembled as she said, “Thank you for not giving up on us. Others told us to stop, but you told us to fight again.” For the team at Fateh Law Corporation, that call was worth every moment spent in the courtroom, every late-night brief, and every obstacle faced. It reminded everyone involved that the purpose of law is not just to argue cases but to restore faith in justice.
The lesson from this story is clear: persistence is powerful. Immigration decisions may seem final, but they are not infallible. The system can make mistakes, and sometimes, those mistakes are serious enough to warrant judicial intervention. The Federal Court of Canada exists precisely for this reason — to ensure that administrative decisions are fair, reasoned, and justifiable. Families who face refusals must know that they have the right to challenge those decisions and that they do not have to accept injustice as fate.
Over the past decade, immigration has become more complex. The rise of automated decision-making tools and rigid processing frameworks has made it harder for genuine applicants to be treated fairly. Many officers rely on standardized refusal templates, ignoring the unique facts of each case. For families applying from abroad, especially from regions like India, the experience can feel impersonal and deeply frustrating. But stories like this prove that legal recourse works. The Federal Court remains a vital check against administrative overreach.
Fateh Law Corporation has represented many families like Jaswinder Kaur’s — parents waiting years for Super Visas, spouses separated due to arbitrary rejections, and skilled workers refused for vague reasons. Each case is a reminder that justice must be fought for, and that hope is often the most powerful legal strategy of all. Every affidavit filed, every argument advanced, is part of a broader mission to bring humanity back into immigration law.
This case also highlights the importance of holding institutions accountable. When IRCC fails to follow its own procedures or reissues bad-faith refusals after settlements, it erodes public trust. Legal challenges are not just about one family; they are about the integrity of the system as a whole. By pursuing costs and exposing unfair conduct, lawyers ensure that similar injustices are less likely to happen in the future.
For Jaswinder Kaur’s family, the victory went far beyond a visa. It was a reaffirmation of their dignity and a recognition that their patience had meaning. They proved that justice, though delayed, can still be achieved. Their courage serves as an example for others who feel lost after a refusal. It shows that giving up is not the solution — persistence is.
Even after receiving their visas, the family often reflects on the experience. It changed them profoundly. They say it made them stronger and more aware of their rights. When they finally arrived in Canada, their first act was not sightseeing but gratitude. They celebrated quietly with their loved ones and expressed heartfelt thanks to the legal team that stood by them.
At Fateh Law Corporation, we believe that every family deserves fairness. Immigration law should be about people, not paperwork. It should be about compassion, not quotas. And while we cannot change the system overnight, we can stand with those who face its harshness. Each case we fight contributes to a broader movement toward accountability and justice.
If your visa has been refused, or if you have faced unreasonable delays, do not assume that the decision is final. You have the right to challenge it through judicial review in the Federal Court of Canada. You have the right to demand a fair assessment. Most importantly, you have the right to be heard. Do not let one refusal define your journey.
Hope is not just an emotion — it is the foundation of every successful legal battle. When combined with patience, preparation, and legal expertise, it becomes a force that can overcome even the most rigid bureaucracy. Jaswinder Kaur’s story is proof of that. Their family did not have an easy path, but they stayed the course, trusted the process, and ultimately won.
Canadian immigration may have changed, but justice remains possible. The road may be long, but light exists at the end of the tunnel. With the right guidance, families can reclaim their dignity and move forward.
Fateh Law Corporation, a Canadian immigration lawyer, continues to advocate for fairness, transparency, and accountability in Canadian immigration.. The firm remains dedicated to helping families challenge wrongful refusals, unreasonable delays, and unfair decisions. The goal is not just to win individual cases but to make the immigration system more humane and just for everyone.
If you or your family have faced a wrongful refusal or delay, you are not alone. There is help available. Contact Fateh Law Corporation to learn about your options, including judicial review, mandamus applications for delayed cases, and strategic legal reapplications. Book a consultation with Mr. Navratan Singh Fateh, Barrister and Solicitor in Canada and Advocate in India, with over eleven years of experience litigating immigration matters before the Federal Court of Canada.
Visit www.navratanfateh.com to schedule your consultation and take the first step toward justice. Because no family should have to fight alone, and no genuine application should be lost to bureaucracy.
Justice in immigration is no longer automatic. It must be pursued. It must be earned. And as Jaswinder Kaur’s family proved, when you refuse to give up, justice will always find its way home.
